३ मंसिर २०८३, बुधबार

For Friendship on Equal Terms and a Well-Managed Border

Editorial

Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s visit to India is more than a formal meeting between two governments. It is an opportunity to make clear the principles on which Nepal wishes to advance its sovereignty, national interests and relations with its neighbour. In talks with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Nepal should extend a hand of friendship on the basis of sovereign equality, mutual respect and fair benefit. It is natural for Nepalis to welcome India’s development. Wishing India continued progress and raising Nepal’s legitimate concerns are not contradictory.

Nepal and India share deep historical, social, cultural and economic ties. This closeness offers both countries significant opportunities for cooperation. But lasting relations cannot be built by overlooking existing imbalances and unresolved issues. In Nepal, calls to review the 1950 Treaty of Peace and Friendship in light of changing circumstances have been made for many years. In 2014, the two prime ministers agreed to review, adjust and update that treaty and other bilateral agreements. That understanding should now move towards implementation.

The open border is a distinctive feature of Nepal–India relations. Nepal’s policy is to manage, regularize and properly record movement across it. Effective mechanisms are needed to facilitate the movement of people and goods through designated crossing points, maintain reliable entry and exit records, strengthen joint monitoring in border areas, and prevent human trafficking, illegal trade and other cross-border crimes. Such measures would preserve the family, social and economic ties of border communities while strengthening security and administrative accountability in both countries.

Debate about border management should be grounded in facts and responsibility. Nepal’s 2021 national census recorded Indian citizens as approximately 0.5 percent of the country’s total population. The census data therefore does not support the claim that the open border is making Nepalis a minority in their own country. At the same time, public concerns about undocumented movement, encroachment, illegal trade and security challenges in border areas should not be dismissed. The two governments should establish a shared system for managing the border on the basis of evidence.

The boundary dispute must also remain a priority in talks. Nepal regards Limpiyadhura, Lipulekh and Kalapani as its territory and has conveyed its position to India through diplomatic notes. Prime Minister Shah should urge Modi to advance dialogue on the basis of historical treaties, maps and evidence. If the friendship between the two countries is to grow stronger, the boundary issue cannot be left unresolved indefinitely. A clear process for negotiations and timely progress are needed. Nepal’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs has also said that the dispute should be resolved through diplomacy and on the basis of historical evidence.

Both sides should be able to see mutual benefit in their economic relationship. In the last fiscal year, Nepal–India merchandise trade exceeded Rs 1.46 trillion, while Nepal’s trade deficit with India was reported at about Rs 952 billion. Reducing this imbalance will require easier access for Nepali products to the Indian market, solutions to non-tariff barriers, reliable transit alternatives and predictable trade rules. The prime minister should state these priorities clearly, and India should provide Nepali goods and services with smoother access to its market.

Progress on air-entry routes, energy, infrastructure and development cooperation could be among the useful outcomes of the visit. But signed agreements and project inaugurations alone should not be treated as measures of success. Every understanding should include a clear implementation timeline, responsible agencies and a mechanism for monitoring progress. Nepal should respect India’s legitimate concerns, and India should show equal respect for Nepal’s sovereign decisions, security and development priorities.

Prime Minister Shah should deliver the message of the Nepali people with confidence: Nepal wants to be a good friend of India, and that friendship must rest on equality, trust and mutual respect. Nepal can welcome India’s progress while protecting its own rights and interests. A commitment to better manage the open border, correct longstanding imbalances and resolve disputes through evidence and dialogue can take the relationship to a new level. At his meeting with Modi, Nepal should speak with the confidence of a sovereign nation—for clarity and respect are the strongest foundations of friendship.

Show More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button