४ मंसिर २०८३, बिहीबार

The Red Carpet Cannot Conceal the Power Struggle: Shenzhen’s Real Test

Muna Chand

Chinese President Xi Jinping went to Shenzhen airport on Wednesday to welcome US President Donald Trump. It was more than an elaborate display of diplomatic protocol. Last September, Trump had welcomed Xi at the airport in Washington; Xi has now returned the gesture. It is a rare occasion in recent decades for a Chinese president to greet a foreign head of state at an airport. But a red carpet cannot erase disputes over trade, technology and security. It signals respect, not policy agreement.

That is also what makes the meeting reportedly scheduled for Thursday in Shenzhen between Xi, Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin significant. The leaders of the three countries are set to meet together for the first time in a trilateral format. Yet describing the gathering as a summit to rewrite the world order would be an exaggeration. It is taking place on the sidelines of APEC, whose central focus is trade and regional economic cooperation. The meeting’s real value will lie not in the leaders’ public statements, but in whether they establish concrete mechanisms to reduce tensions.

The US side has signalled that arms control may be discussed. China, however, has argued that its nuclear arsenal is not on a par with those of the United States and Russia, and that it would be unfair to expect it to join trilateral disarmament talks at this stage. Meanwhile, the New START treaty, which limited strategic nuclear weapons held by the United States and Russia, expired in February 2026. Its expiry has increased the need for the two countries to seek a new framework for nuclear arms control. Given China’s stated position, it does not seem realistic to expect a binding trilateral agreement to emerge from the Shenzhen meeting. Such an agreement appears unlikely.

A more realistic outcome would not be an immediate arms-reduction deal, but an understanding to keep communication channels open during crises, reduce the risk of miscalculation and contain nuclear competition. Without such arrangements, the three leaders’ appearance on the same platform would amount to little more than a symbolic achievement. China has described the meeting as important for peace and stability, but has yet to provide concrete details on how that goal might be achieved—or what results the meeting could deliver.

The Jensen Huang episode points to another sensitive dimension of the talks. Nvidia’s former chief executive may have been targeted in a foreign intelligence operation, according to reports, prompting the company’s board to launch an independent investigation. The company has said there is no basis to believe that national security or confidential technology was compromised; the espionage allegation has not been substantiated. Although Huang stepped down on November 12, Trump has publicly supported him and said he would have no objection if Huang returned as chief executive. But political support is not the same as an investigative finding. With inquiries by US officials and congressional committees continuing, Trump’s defence does not resolve the questions surrounding the case.

The episode cannot be reduced to a dispute over personal relationships. Artificial intelligence chips are no longer merely commercial products; they are tied to economic competition, military capabilities and national security. The allegations involving Huang, and Trump’s public support for him, highlight tensions between personal access in technology policy and institutional security checks. There is no confirmation, however, that the matter is on Shenzhen’s formal agenda. Its significance lies less in whether it is raised at the meeting than in the broader context it reveals about the depth of US–China competition.

Portraying the meeting as a “new Yalta” would also be driven more by fear than by evidence. At Yalta, major powers discussed the postwar geopolitical order and spheres of influence. There is no evidence that a similar arrangement is being negotiated in Shenzhen. Still, the concerns of smaller countries are real: if agreements between major powers begin to determine their sovereignty, security or regional future, opposition is natural. Dialogue among great powers is necessary, but it does not give them the right to displace the voices of countries affected by their decisions.

Nepal should assess this summit not as a victory for any one side, but by its consequences for the country’s security and economic interests. Only concrete efforts to reduce nuclear risks, greater stability in technology trade and respect for the sovereignty of smaller nations would turn Shenzhen’s red-carpet diplomacy into a substantive achievement. Otherwise, the display may soften the appearance of great-power competition for a time without changing its harsh reality.

Show More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button